Skip to main content

Customer Experience - A Banking Tale of Mystery and Imagination

After some investigation into SME CRM Nimble and Freshsales and travel management software traform today is the day of a reflection on customer orientation in one of the industries that managed to become almost indispensable in our lives.

Banks.

So let me tell you ...

A Bank Tale of Mystery and Imagination

But not an invented one. This is life in 2016.

Imagine the following extremely uncommon scenario: You want a mortgage for a house. Imagine also that you have a fairly good income, so you want to pay down fast. After all interest rates in NZ are still pretty high compared to other developed nations – although they are very low for NZ standards. And remember – one of the basic premises of neoliberalism is that everybody has equal negotiation powers (the Kiwi in me says “Yeah, right” to that one …).

What are the variables you have in a mortgage? The total amount, interest rate, pay down period, term of fixing the interest rate, unless you go floating, that is, and the start of the pay down.

So you start doing some maths on what you are able and willing to regularly pay and start negotiating a rate, finally coming to an agreement, clearly communicating that you want a fixed term of one year, and a calculated pay down period of, say 10 years, and weekly payments.

You are happy.

The documentation arrives, actually three pieces of it.
  • A summary of the agreement

  • Terms and Conditions on about 30 pages of legalese. No need to go through it here; it basically details out that the bank has all rights and you none.

  • A third document that tells you that the bank is so happy to do business with you that they give you a cash incentive of 1% of the mortgage amount. Nice, but why not reducing it from the interest rate, thus faster reducing the principal – or improving your cash flow by making ongoing payments smaller? After all this money goes directly away from their income in the year of fixed interest. Do some maths by reducing it off the accumulated interest of the one-year contract period or only off the principal that remains after one year. Observe the interest rates. You will be amazed.

There is only one reason for doing it this way: Bind the customer for longer using a clause in the incentive document (yeah, there it is: a multiyear condition …) and now the bank nicely gets this returned in multiples as the higher interest rate leaves you with a higher remaining principal after the year, means more interest for them … Of course you can put the money onto a savings account and take it off the money you need next year – but I deviate.

Try negotiating this ‘incentive’ into the interest rate and let me know the outcome.

Now you look into your main parameters:

Amount: Check.

Interest rate: Check. But what is this repetitive statement about the interest rate might change, formulated in a way that it might change even during the fix period (of one year, as we assume so far)? Hhmm, confusion.

Fixing period: 2 years? Oops, didn’t we say 1?

Calculated pay down period: 30 years! Yes, THIRTY. Assuming 4 per cent of interest and a $ 100,000 mortgage this makes an accumulated interest of $ 71,869 as opposed to $ 21,494. This is a bit of a difference.

Payment period: Every two weeks.

Payment start: 3 weeks after start of the mortgage. Hhhmm, you didn’t say anything about that but there is no reason for you to wait with the payment start, right?

Well, at least the bank got one parameter right.

But still, you feel somewhat cheated upon.

The remaining question is whether these errors are genuine or part of a method. After all, nearly every single parameter was wrong in favor of the bank. Even the seemingly generous incentive is built in a way that it is least beneficial to you.

I learn two lessons from this tale:
  • Obviously: Read what you sign. It might not be what you expect
  • Even in the best case this shows that banks care more about securing their income than about the customer. Although this is a short sighted position, because experiences like this are shared. And this erodes the same income that shall get protected
Of course, some phone calls later all the parameters are fixed. But still, a bad taste remains …

So, what could be different?

On the outset this is blatantly obvious: Deliver documentation as per the agreement. As said, in the best case this failure shows poor process. The worst case is, well, worse …

In our scenario there was one variable (the start of the payment) untreated. As a perhaps unexperienced borrower you might not always think of it, as a bank you probably should have asked, not assumed something. Again, poor process, or …

While it is understandable that banks try to protect their business it does not show good faith to attempt a lock in of the customer or to attach 30+ pages of terms and conditions to a simple thing as a mortgage. The lock in happens via tying ‘incentives’ to longer term conditions or asking for securities that are far in excess of the value of the mortgaged property. This is simply to make it harder to change to the competition whereas the better way would just be to be better, easier to deal with, and continuing to have the overall better package.

Part of this could be limiting the terms and conditions to something that the average customer can easily understand in a short time. This can be done. A mortgage broker who is a friend of mine tells me that there is a bank around that has terms limited to three pages only, with the offer summary being a one-pager.

The Bottom Line

All this boils down to customer orientation rather than product orientation. Starting with an outside-in view rather than an inside-out one would help to easier contribute to the customer’s job-to-be-done while reducing internal process cost. This will make the customer want to return without the need for tying him/her via clauses.

Part of this is a continuing digital transformation but most importantly there is a need for a culture change. There are new fintech companies emerging left, right, and center that address these issues and threaten to disrupt the banks’ business.

Time to think.

And act.

Last Year's Top 5 Popular Posts

A Love Affair - Nimble Smart Contacts for Outlook Mobile

Social Selling pioneer Nimble has an awesome start into 2017. First it got number 1 in CRM satisfaction by G2Crowd earlier in January, then friend and CRM godfather Paul Greenberg named Nimble a winner of the 2017 CRM Watchlist awards, and now Nimble announces the Smart Contacts add-in for Outlook, a deep integration into Outlook for iOS, with an integration into Outlook for Android coming soon. The Nimble Smart Contacts add-in brings the power of Nimble’s view on contacts to Outlook for mobile users, after the widget and Outlook add-on already offered this functionality for the web- and Outlook clients. The add-on follows the philosophy that for most companies the e-mail account is still their CRM system; given this, this is a straightforward enhancement. Nimble acknowledges that there are two main email systems used in businesses: Gmail and Office365, and now fully supports them both. This integration delivers the profiling data that the Nimble back end gathers practically at any plac…

Mass Distraction - The Case for a Consolidated Marketing Platform

These days, customer experiences increasingly need to be delivered with the help of technology. This does not mean that direct interactions and people are no more important in marketing, sales, or service; on the contrary, but that an increasing number of customers is using the web, social media, chat, or an app to identify suitable products or services or to resolve an issue, when needed. The Customer Executive Board found that 57 per cent of the buying process is already completed before sales personnel get engaged. A Cisco retail study confirms the American Express findings and states that around 60 per cent of all in-store purchases start their journey electronically. The American Express Global Barometer claims that 60 per cent of all customers abandoned a purchase because of poor service experiences. Over the past 20 or so years the way products and services get sold and customer service as well as marketing get delivered to customers changed dramatically. Gone are the times wher…

Google and SAP - A Marriage in the Clouds

On Mach 8, 2017, SAP and Google announced another marriage in the cloud during Google’s Cloud Next event: SAP HANA is certified on Google’s Cloud Platform GCP, and is generally available now. SAP Cloud Platform and more products and solutions are to follow. The Google Cloud Launcher marketplace will be utilized to offer and deploy to and for customers and partners, starting with SAP HANA, express edition, which is already available, too. Further topics that are covered by this partnership are ·Improving Google’s containerization technologies for enterprise workloads ·Security, privacy, and integrity of customer data in the cloud. As part of this SAP software shall act as a data custodian (NB: How that works in legal and political environments remains to be seen) and joint solutions for access control, governance, risk and compliance shall get developed ·Integrate Google’s G Suite into SAP applications. This has already been implemented for Identity and Access Management. More on the still f…

Clash of Titans

Following all those announcements of AI, machine learning, IoT, IaaS, PaaS and what not over the past months, I was beginning to wonder where the big business software vendors are going. What is the game plan of Microsoft, Oracle, Salesforce, SAP? How does newcomer Adobe fit in there? Maybe Amazon and Google, too; or Facebook. It is a time for another Quo Vadis – this time: Quo Vadis, industry? Clash of Titans In the last about 2 – 3 years we have seen a strong acceleration of innovation, or at least talk about it. -Cloud computing, offering nearly unlimited scalability and elasticity of computing resources has become main stream. Cloud computing also allows for nearly 100 per cent uptime -Since the advent of the iPhone (yes, I know this was earlier than 2013) the proliferation of sensors has increased a lot, resulting in them becoming cheaper and cheaper, allowing for an increasing number of data rich applications -This has also driven fast mobile connectivity, which has become nearly u…

Watson meets Einstein - Elementary my Dear Holmes

This week Salesforce and IBM announced a global strategic partnership to deliver joint, AI based solutions based upon Salesforce Einstein and IBM Watson, their respective AI platforms. The upcoming solutions will be designed to “deliver everage artificial intelligence and enable companies to make smarter decisions, faster than ever before. With the partnership, IBM Watson, the leading AI platform for business, and Salesforce Einstein, AI that powers the world’s #1 CRM, will seamlessly connect to enable an entirely new level of intelligent customer engagement across sales, service, marketing, commerce and more.” IBM Watson will be connected to the Salesforce Intelligent Customer Success Platform in a way that augments the customer specific insights that are delivered by Einstein with its structured and unstructured data that comes from a variety of sources, in order to be able to use specific as well as more generic, yet industry relevant, information. “Together, Watson and Einstein wil…